BASEBALL: Who would win more games: a team of 8 Zack Cozarts, or 8 Victor Martinezes?

I got into a heated debate about this with a friend the other day. Assuming identical pitching staffs, would a team of 8 big bat, bad everything else players be better than a team of 8 defensive wizards who can't hit? via /r/baseball http://www.reddit.com/r/baseball/comments/2lhwax/who_would_win_more_games_a_team_of_8_zack_cozarts/